Tag Archive for ebike injuries

A conservative case for why bike activists suck, ripping US TransSec a new one, and blaming all ebikes for rise in out-of-context injuries

The good news is, I got nine-and-a-half hours of sleep Monday night. The bad news it, my blood sugar was still fucked up yesterday. 

Diabetes sucks. 

And nothing like the feeling that I have the perfect T-shirt to illustrate today’s lead story, only to realize I forgot to do it. 

Oops. 

……….

Um, sure.

A conservative columnist confessed to riding a bike to work. “(Okay, from the railway station to the office. Which is somehow even more stereotypically leftist.)”

But he wishes that “professional activists” would just leave things alone.

It would, frankly, be more pleasant if the professional activists who claim to improve bicycling would stop helping. Because their “help” too often subordinates the interests of the pedal people to the needs of the Everything Leftist Omnicause.

Why, you might ask quizzically?

Because the big, scary liberals in the country’s most liberal city may have gone just a tad too far in suggesting that bike theft victims might want to think twice about calling the police, because interactions with the cops don’t always end well for Black and brown people.

Never mind that a bike thief is just as likely to be white.

Lay aside for the moment the practical impact of a public policy of ignoring bicycle theft on the bicyclists—according to academic research, the often non-white and lower-income bicycle-theft victims—the coalition purports to represent. What is distilled here is the classic Everything Leftist approach to issue analysis. Instead of taking what one might expect to be the single-issue position, even for a largely liberal-to-progressive constituency, that protecting that constituency’s totemic property is important and indeed the core role of a government of laws, the San Francisco Bicycle Coalition takes the Everything Leftist position that the police are bad and therefore it is not appropriate to involve them in dealing with bicycle theft…

This is, for class-dynamics reasons, pretty much what one should expect from a representative nonprofit (the nonprofit industry tends to be left-wing) of a left-wing constituency (the GOP is not looking for high-yield voter registrations among urban bicycle commuters) in a very left-wing city (it is, after all, San Francisco), even if some (or even most) of the ostensible constituents might rather follow a more traditional single-issue line.

It gets worse from there.

Never mind that in more conservative areas, bike advocates tend to be as conservative as those around them. Or that even in liberal San Francisco, the bike coalition continues to fight for the rights and safety of bicyclists.

Frankly, I don’t give a damn about someone’s politics, if they’re willing to fight for my right to ride a bike and get home again in one piece.

So if you disagree with something some bike advocate or organization somewhere has said, then disagree with them. Lord knows, I have. But don’t paint us all with the same brush.

And don’t forget who’s out there fighting for you when you ride your bike to work. Because if you get there safely, it’s probably because someone, somewhere fought for your right to do it.

………

A writer for ebike site Electrek deservedly rips our country’s transportation secretary a new one, for the same reason we mentioned last week about the Highway Administration removing proven safety policies like road diets and bike lanes from their website.

Because they felt like it, evidently. No reason was given, nor did anyone with the government even mention that it had been done.

Writer Jameson Dow‘s takedown is simply a thing of beauty. 

So of course, what is the set of incompetents running the US into the ground to do? Well, ignore the science and try to kill more cyclists.

That’s the move made last week by Sean Duffy, the current squatter at the head of the Department of Transportation. Duffy’s transportation “expertise” comes from being a contestant on Road Rules: All Stars, a reality TV travel game show…

But lower congestion and roads that are safe for cyclists are things that Duffy simply cannot abide. If people ride bikes, they’re not using oil, and then the oil industry which has given Duffy hundreds of thousands of dollars of bribes over his political career might have slightly lower profits. Congestion, too, hurts all drivers and breathers of air (that’s you), but helps the oil industry as people burn gas while they sit still.

And all of this comes on top of the $23 billion in additional fuel costs that Duffy wants to saddle you with, which he announced on his first day. As a reward for this, oil companies paid for a vacation for Duffy’s family.

This isn’t the only indication of Duffy’s hatred of bikes and love of road accidents. Duffy previously pulled funding for bike lanes, calling them “hostile to motor vehicles.” Notably, in conflicts between motor vehicles and bicycles, motor vehicles are typically the more violent participant.

Go ahead and read the whole thing. It’s worth it.

We’ll wait.

………

I could just scream.

Once again, a major hospital has studied ebike crashes, and concluded that things are getting worse.

And once again, without putting the injury rate in context with ebike ridership, and lumping every type of ebike together, as if a Class 1 ped-assist bike is as dangerous as an illegal electric motorbike.

According to public TV station KPBS,

To better understand trends, the researchers analyzed data from the California Highway Patrol’s Statewide Integrated Traffic Records System, examining collisions involving e-bikes and traditional bicycles from 2018 through 2024. The total number of collisions analyzed were 4,035 involving e- bikes and 58,332 on traditional bicycles.

The results found that injuries on e-bikes occurred on younger riders and on riders more likely to ride at unsafe speeds. They also occurred more frequently in affluent communities.

So, a reasonable conclusion would be that illegal ebikes which allow dangerous speeds are more dangerous than regular bicycles, especially for young children ill-equipped to handle excess speeds.

Not “ebikes are dangerous,” which seems to sum up their report, and every other one I’ve seen.

Even the cops don’t seem to know what they’re talking about. Literally, according to the Los Angeles Times.

The rapid popularity of e-bikes has also made it difficult for law enforcement agencies, regulatory groups and medical officials to quantify what injuries were being caused by e-bikes.

Law enforcement agencies reached by The Times said some local agencies have not collected specific data on e-bike crashes or citations because the problem is so new to many areas and numbers are often difficult to parse, with e-bikes injuries often intermingled with traditional bike injuries.

So they don’t know which injuries are caused by which type of bikes, but they are somehow able to parse out that ebike injuries are worse than regular bikes, whether that ebike is a ped-assist cargo bike or a high speed electric motorbike.

As I’ve said before, any study like this will be worth no more than a few sheets of toilet paper unless, and until, they a) put ebike injuries in context with ebike ridership, and b) clearly define which type of ebike causes the most serious injuries.

It’s a pretty damned easy conclusion to make. Faster and more powerful ebikes tend to result in more serious injuries, on average.

But somehow, all these noted scientists and physicians seem incapable of making that simple observation.

Thanks to Megan for the heads-up.

………

I promised you CicLAvia pictures, and by God, that’s what you’re going to get.

David forwards these photos from Sunday’s event.

Photos by David

His photos belie what appeared to me to be a more sparsely attended event than in year’s past. Although that could have something to do with just sadly passing by on our way to celebrate my wife’s birthday.

Then again, it could also have something to do with simultaneous open streets events in Santa Monica and Long Beach — all sponsored by Metro, as in what the hell were they thinking? — combined with the final of the World Cup.

Meanwhile, Streetsblog’s Joe Linton offers an open thread about Sunday’s CicLAvia, along with his usually great photos, while WeHo Times offers photos and a writeup, as well.

The Long Beach Press Telegram reports on that city’s Beach Streets open streets event. But they don’t want you to know about it, so they hid it behind their draconian paywall.

………

Remembering undoubtedly the funniest bike rider in human history.

Or maybe just the funniest human, period.

Bluesky post

………

The war on cars may be a myth, but the war on bikes just keeps on going.

No bias here. The planned World Naked Bike Ride has been cancelled in Buffalo, New York, after organizers received a number of death threats amid “overwhelming disapproval” from the community. Which is kind of the point, that participants strip down knowing many will disapprove, so that people actually see them. But if you’re so offended that you threaten to kill someone, get a good mirror, because you’re the one with the problem. 

Police in West Midlands, England seized and destroyed a perfectly legal e-cargo bike after somehow concluding that it was an illegal electric motorbike — even though they claim they only gave the rider a ticket for not having insurance, which isn’t required under UK law.

No bias here, either. Irish government ministers are once again reviving the eternal question of whether bike riders should be forced to wear high viz,  helmets and license plates, the latter of which would have to be as big as your butt if drivers are expected to read it at a reasonable distance; meanwhile, Road.cc quotes an advocate saying “Fewer people cycling or scooting does not make roads safer.Then again, why not go the full monty and require us to dress up like clowns with our full names and addresses embossed both front and back?

……….

Local 

The iconic Watts Towers are getting new park space in time for the ’28 Olympics, including walking paths and bike racks.

Time is running out to apply for Metro’s Adopt A Bike Program.

Speaking of Metro, the LA County transportation authority wants to flush another $100 million down the highway widening toilet, as if they’ve never heard of induced demand. Or maybe they’re sure just one more lane will solve the whole thing this time.

On that note, Streets For All wants you to contact the Metro Board before tomorrow’s meeting, and tell them to stop defunding open streets, fund transit instead of highways, and fix their damn board structure.

 

State

No surprise here. California might be in the middle of a heat wave wrapped in a climate emergency, but Californians still want their gas-powered cars.

This is the cost of traffic violence. A 72-year old Seal Beach woman is finally home and talking to the media, following two weeks in the ICU and a month in a rehab facility after she was struck by a teen on an illegal Surron e-motorbike, resulting in a broken leg, hand, nose and jaw. And yet, even knowing what the kid was riding, KTLA-7 still manages to conflate ebikes and e-motorcycles.

No bias here, either. A San Diego TV station reports a 53-year-old man riding a bicycle was seriously injured in the city’s Grantville neighborhood Monday night, by a driver who “swerved to miss him…but the bicycle collided with the front right of the vehicle.” So, the driver didn’t hit the person on the bike, because the bike hit the car, and the driver did everything he could to avoid that two-wheeled kamikaze hellbent on getting his blood all over that poor, innocent grill. 

No, an ebike takeover did not paralyze El Cajon traffic, with “Some cars…completely surrounded by bicycles.” Because there is not a single bicycle shown in the video of around 50 teens on electric motorbikes.

Tres shock! A survey of bike riders in Santa Cruz County finds that a majority of bicyclists don’t feel safe on the roads. Kind of like bicyclists everywhere else in the US. 

This is who we share the road with. Eighty-six-year old Paul Pelosi, husband of former US House Speaker Nancy and survivor of a rightwing hammer attack, has been charged with hit-and-run for driving away after hitting a parked Tesla in Napa County.

 

National

Velo says blame UCI rules for why you can’t find a 25 mm rim anymore, even if you pinky swear that you don’t intend to ever race your bike.

Tragic news from Milwaukee, where an 84-year old man riding a bike was killed when he was hit by a public bus, on a street scheduled to get curb-protected bike lanes sometime this year. But whenever it happens, it will be too late.

This is the cost of traffic violence, part two. An Ohio congregation is mourning, after the church’s pastor was killed when he was struck by a truck driver while riding his bike on a shared-use path, and attempted to cross the roadway. However, the driver won’t be charged, because it’s apparently open-season on bike-riding pastors in Ohio.

In a paywalled story, a 39-year old New Orleans woman was convicted of a) killing a 62-year old man riding a bicycle in a hit-and-run, then b) fatally strangling her finance’ just over a year later, while out on bond for the hit-and-run.

The Savanah, Georgia police department is hosting a community bike ride, which is a damn good idea everywhere.

 

International

Momentum looks at the world’s most innovative bicycling infrastructure, but doesn’t seem to have added anything from the last time they repeated this story.

Good point. Alberta bike riders make the case for why the province’s new portal to complain about bike lanes and everything bicycle-related that might conceivably inconvenience drivers even a tad bit has to be open for people expressing the other side of the question, too.

This is the cost of traffic violence, part three. A 71-year old Engineering professor in Halifax, Nova Scotia was remembered as a mentor and father figure, and a leader in the local Islamic community, after he was killed by a careless motorist in a dooring while riding his bike. But hey, at least the driver got a ticket, right? 

A British woman asks for drivers to pay more attention, after she suffered a fractured skull and TBI in a hit-and-run dooring, but doesn’t remember a thing.

Dublin officials are removing chicanes from a local street that had been installed to slow ebike riders after just ten days, because they forced bike riders and pedestrians to swerve onto the sidewalks. I mean, who could have possibly foreseen that placing awkward obstacles in the middle of the street might cause just the teensiest bit of a problem?

A 27-year old driver in Kyiv, Ukraine faces up to ten years behind bars for attempting to pass another vehicle on the right while driving drunk at a high rate of speed, and slamming into a 17-year old boy and his father riding their bikes on the shoulder, killing the younger man instantly and seriously injuring his dad.

 

Competitive Cycling

Another day, another broken collarbone at the Tour de France. This time, it was German rider Florian Lipowitz who crashed at high speed in the final kilometers of Tuesday’s time trial; he was running 5th overall, and had the second-fastest time at the third time check.

World champion Remco Evenepoel won his second straight stage after destroying the field in the time trial, but only made a 28-second dent in Tadej Pogačar’s five-minute lead in yellow. And Lipowitz had been a key consigliere for Pogačar’s team.

Not even the Tour de France is safe from road raging drivers, as American cyclist Brandon McNulty was brake-checked by an angry driver while on his way to the start of Tuesday’s time trial; he was knocked off his bike, but “relatively unscathed.” How do you say schmuck in French? Oh yeah, it’s “schmuck.”

Velo examines why this year’s Tour de France is faster than ever. Which could have something to do with all those broken collarbones. Or maybe they’re because UCI keeps waking cyclists up in the middle of the night for a drug test.

 

Finally…

Maybe if you pedal hard enough, your bike will fly, too. We still don’t know what Einstein’s bike saddle is worth, because it’s relative.

And this is what happens when the headline writer doesn’t bother to read the story.

………

Be safe, and stay healthy. And get vaccinated, already.

Oh, and fuck Putin.

 

Ebike & e-moto injuries rise 2.5 times faster than sales, and two teens busted for leading vicious Hermosa Beach attack

Day 335 of LA’s Vision Zero failure to end traffic deaths by 2025. 

………

It’s Day 4 of the 11th Annual BikinginLA Holiday Fund Drive. And we’re already off to a rip-roaring start!

So let’s all join in a round of applause for Rob, Robs, Ross, Stephen, Joshua, Eric, Johannes, David and Andrew for their generous support to help keep all the best bike news and advocacy coming your way every day. 

So don’t wait! Take a moment to consider what this site is worth to you, how much you can afford to give, and donate now!

After all, what other bike sites offer all the best news and a cute little corgi spokesdog?

………

At last, we get a little context for the rise in ebike injuries — although, as usual, there’s no distinction between injury rates for ped-assist ebikes and e-motorbikes.

According to the New York Times, Marin County worked to get California law changed after a 15-year old girl barely survived a fall while riding on the back of a friend’s ebike, prompting a local surgeon to look into rising injury rates.

As the pandemic continued, the number of e-bike accidents increased. “You would expect that,” Alfrey says, “because sales were skyrocketing.” Indeed, in 2022, over a million e-bikes were sold in the United States, up from 287,000 in 2019, according to the Light Electric Vehicle Association. But what really struck Alfrey and Maa was that e-bike injuries were far more serious than those sustained on conventional bikes. Maa says they were more like what’s seen in motorcycle crashes. A pelvic fracture, for example, was uncommon on a pedal bicycle — only about 6 percent of conventional cycling injuries. For e-bike crashes, though, it was 25 percent.

The most alarming difference was the fatality rate. “On a pedal bike, the chance of dying from an injury is about three-tenths of 1 percent,” Alfrey says. On an e-bike, the data indicated, it was 11 percent.

These findings signaled what was unfolding around the country. During the same four-year period when nationwide sales quadrupled, e-bike injuries increased by a factor of 10, to 23,493 from 2,215, according to the National Electronic Injury Surveillance System. A study by the University of California, San Francisco, found that from 2017 to 2022, head injuries from e-bike accidents increased 49-fold.

Which means ebike injuries rose 2.5 times faster than ebike sales.

Now we finally know.

The paper goes on to note that Class 2 throttle-controlled ebikes have claimed the overwhelming majority of the market.

By “throttle devices,” he is referring to Class 2 machines, which have captured an estimated two-thirds of the e-bike market. According to PeopleForBikes, the rationale in 2015 for creating a class for bikes with throttles — which can eliminate even the modest exercise benefits of pedal assistance — was that many e-bikes already had them, and the trade organization didn’t want to exclude those products and companies.

But to Mittelstaedt and others, it’s inappropriate to consider these vehicles to be “bikes” at all. “The essence of bicycling is pedaling,” Mittelstaedt says. “A machine propelled by a motorcycle throttle just shouldn’t be considered a bicycle. It can go from zero to 20 faster than a regular bike without any exertion at all.”

As we’ve repeatedly stressed, anything that can travel faster than 28 mph isn’t legally an ebike. And anything without pedals isn’t a bicycle.

Some manufacturers — but not governments — have taken it upon themselves to call such machines “Class 4” e-bikes. Others refer to them as “out-of-class electric vehicles”; bicycle-advocacy groups, which want to avoid being associated with these machines, prefer “e-motos.” In any case, they aren’t bicycles, nor are they street legal without registration and a license, yet they still show up regularly on roads and bike paths. One online influencer called Sur Ronster, who also has a retail business called Ronster Rides, posts videos of bands of teenagers, dozens strong, outdoing one another’s daredevil feats at breakneck speed on city streets and highways.

Like this dual-engine Chinese ebike with a top speed of 46 mph, which would classify it as a motorbike in virtually every American state — yet is somehow still sold as a ped-assist bike.

It’s worth taking the time to read the whole Times story. Because it’s long past time we started making those differences clear.

But if you’re in a hurry, you can catch the Cliff Notes version in a brief interview with the writer.

Wait, is Cliff Notes even a thing anymore?

Meanwhile, Harley Davidson is teaming with the San Diego County Bicycle Coalition to host a course on ebike safety, while the San Diego police issued warnings about riders on illegal e-motos capable of 80 mph zooming through traffic and crowded areas.

And Electrek warns parents about the dangers of Sur Ron and other high-powered electric motos. Thanks Ellectrek for the link.

And no, I don’t think they don’t mean ped-assist bikes.

………

Police in Hermosa Beach arrested two ebike — actually e-moto — riding teens for leading the vicious gang beatdown given to a man carrying his takeout pizza.

The boys were part of a group of five kids aged 13-15 identified by police as the attackers, who only broke off the assault when one of the boys mistakenly yelled that the victim, who has not been publicly identified, was dead.

Another man came forward after news of the attack surfaced, saying he, too, had been attacked by a gang of ebike-riding teens.

Initial police reports sparked angry comments for implying that the victim had somehow done something to instigate the assault, which the police later retracted.

………

Bike deals are continuing post-Black Friday with today’s Cyber Monday deals, with the best specials highlighted by Cycling News and Cycling Weekly.

………

A podcast host talks with two millennials who quit their jobs to bike around the world, and wrote a book about it.

Twitter post

………

A Freemont CA rancher has installed a gate across a formerly open roadway, blocking a path used by bicyclists and hikers for years.

Thanks to Megan for forwarding the video.

………

A YouTube video considers how Victoria, British Columbia, population 92,000, tripled its bicycling rate in just 11 years.

Thanks to Norm for the video. 

………

………

The war on cars may be a myth, but the war on bikes just keeps on going.

No bias here. A Sunnyvale website says residents feel their voice is being “drowned out by a vocal cyclist lobby,” because they value their God-given right to park their cars on the curbs over the safety of people on two wheels. There’s that mythical bike lobby raising its ugly head again, and Hulk-smashing all who don’t bow down before it. 

A man and woman face charges in Lafayette, Louisiana after allegedly yelling at another woman, beating her and threatening her with a gun before yet another beatdown in front of her kid, all because her husband committed the crime of yelling at the woman to slow her car down while he was riding bikes with the couple’s young son.

But sometimes it’s the people on two wheels behaving badly.

A 60-year old Gainesville, Florida man faces 11 separate charges, including possession of meth, resisting arrest and, yes, littering, after he ran away on foot when police tried to stop him for riding salmon and without lights on his bike.

A British reporter launches a “bold social experiment” to see if he can get his phone stolen by ebike-riding — actually, e-motorbike — thieves, then track it to reveal their location. Thanks again to Megan for the video.

………

Local 

The Malibu City Council approved a comprehensive, $50 million safety improvement plan for Pacific Coast Highway, including new and improved sidewalks and 9.7 miles of new bike lanes, with just a single dissenting vote.

 

State

Calbike will reveal its legislative agenda for the coming year in a webinar this Wednesday; sign up here for the 10 am video conference.

Police in Anaheim have arrested the alleged hit-and-run driver accused of hitting a 12-year old boy riding an ebike last week, leaving the kid with a concussion, broken leg and multiple bruises; 29-year old Fullerton resident Jonathan Diaz reportedly took off on foot after crashing his car a few blocks after he struck the boy’s bike, leaving behind evidence he was under the influence.

 

National

Bike Magazine is back in print for the first time since the heady pre-pandemic days of 2020.

Cycling Savvy explains how to navigate diverging traffic lanes on your bicycle.

Velo makes the case for why you should skip the crappy bikes, and buy your kid a decent bicycle to learn how to ride this Christmas.

A writer for Strongtowns makes the case that Complete Streets has run its course, leaving cities with “expensive, over-engineered corridors that win awards but fail the people they claim to serve.” Although I’d question whether the study the story is based on cherry-picked cities where Complet Streets failed, rather than where they have succeeded. 

Seattle has launched a commercial e-cargo bike program to encourage businesses to adopt cleaner alternatives to standard delivery trucks.

A pair of Seattle bike advocacy groups have purchased their own ebike-towed bike lane sweeper to clear out the wet, soggy leaves that pile up next to the curb.

 

International

Sometimes the best use of a bicycle isn’t riding it. A nine-year old Peruvian boy raffled off his beloved bicycle to fund a trip to Canada for the World Mathematics Championship, and came back home with a gold medal.

Despite rumors of budget cuts and caps on bike prices, Britain’s Bike to Work program that pays for bike commuters’ bicycles will be largely unchanged in the county’s new budget.

A study from Limerick, Ireland showed that the city’s new bike lanes “maintained or improved” access for ambulances, which could use the bike lanes to get through traffic when needed. So much for the myth that bike lanes keep emergency vehicles from getting through.

British bike writer and historian Carlton Reid talks with American Eric Hassett, who moved from Colorado to Malmö, Sweden to help design Thule’s sleek new pannier system.

This is why people keep dying on the streets. Colombian Tour de France sprinter Fernando Gaviria was given a suspended sentence for drunk driving in Monaco — despite being more than five times over the legal limit. Seriously, there’s no excuse for driving under the influence, no matter who you are.

That’s more like it. Croatia’s Silba Island has replaced engine noise with the sound of bike wheels, after banning cars from the island five decades ago.

Young workers in North Korea’s Wonsan Kalma Coastal Tourist Area are only turning up to state jobs on paper, instead ferrying goods and tourists on bicycles and motorbikes, rather than working without salaries or rations.

After biking nearly 400 miles across South Korea, a Malaysian writer wonders if a cross-country bikeway could unlock that country’s tourism potential, as well.

 

Competitive Cycling

Former Dutch pro Stef Clement is calling for cyclists to pass a proficiency test and “crash course” before they can ride in the peloton, while his countryman Tom Dumoulin says protective clothing should be normalized for pro cyclists.

The bicycle the legendary Eddy Merckx rode when he broke the hour record in Mexico City in 1972, cycling 49.4 kilometers, or 30.69 miles, in one hour stands on display in the Brussels metro station named after him.

Twenty-one-year old cycling rookie Isaac del Toro was named Mexico’s sportsman of the year with the country’s highest sports honor, the 2025 National Sports Award, after winning winning 16 pro races, nearly winning the Giro and climbing to third in the world rankings in just his first year on the WorldTour.

Thirty-five-year old Colombian cyclist Esteban Chaves called it a career after 16 years in the pro peloton, including five Grand Tour victories, podium finishes in both the Giro and the Vuelta, and winning Il Lombardia; he called it quits after he didn’t receive an offer for the upcoming season.

 

Finally…

Now you, too, can turn your garage into a virtual fortress to protect your two-wheeled pride and joy. Go back to the future of bicycling.

And who needs a nightclub when you can DJ from the seat of your bicycle?

………

Be safe, and stay healthy. And get vaccinated, already.

Oh, and fuck Putin.